bytebuster: (CH-biang3biang3mien4)
[personal profile] bytebuster
Q: Can “З” be used without a word following it?

In English, it is acceptable to use "with" without a word to follow it.

I would go to the dance, but I don't have anyone to go with.

Is this kind of construction acceptable in Ukrainian? If not, what would be the Ukrainian equivalent of this kind of construction?


A:

That with and the like at the end of the sentence is very typical of English (and some other Germanic languages), but it is absolutely un-Slavic in general and un-Ukrainian specifically. That is called "hanging prepositions", Ukrainian does not allow that and it always moves those prepositions into the middle of the sentence. If we take your example, Ukrainian will put the words in it in such an order:

..., but I don't have anyone to go with → ..., but I don't have anyone with whom to go

That particular sentence in Ukrainian is:

Я б пішов (masc.)/пішла (fem.) на танці, та немає з ким.

As you can see, since the preposition is no more hanging into the abyss of the end of the sentence, there must be something to follow it, which is usually the pronouns хто "who" or що "what" in the case which is demanded by the preposition. In your example it is ким which is хто "who" in the Instrumental case, for з needs Instrumental.

This account has disabled anonymous posting.
If you don't have an account you can create one now.
HTML doesn't work in the subject.
More info about formatting

If you are unable to use this captcha for any reason, please contact us by email at support@dreamwidth.org

Сторінку створено П'ятниця, 30 Травень 2025 17:03

Травень 2025

П В С Ч П С Н
   1 234
567891011
12131415161718
192021222324 25
262728293031 
Створено з Dreamwidth Studios

За стиль дякувати